WHY YOUR WEBSITE ISN’T CONVERTING, marketing article by Blue Cactus Digital
BACK TO BLOG

WHY YOUR WEBSITE ISN’T CONVERTING

Your website might be getting plenty of visits and still not bringing in sales, enquiries or sign-ups. That is frustrating, but it is usually fixable. The cause is rarely one big thing. It is more often a handful of small frictions that add up and send people away.

Start by asking people outside your circle

When did you last ask someone who isn't a friend or family member how they found your website? Or what they thought of it?

Websites are subjective. You probably like yours, otherwise you would have changed it. But the people who matter are strangers who arrive with a question and very little patience. Ask recent customers, enquirers or supporters what nearly stopped them. Ask what they were looking for first. Their answers will tell you more than any opinion in your own team.

If you can, watch someone use the site without helping them. Where they pause is where you are losing people.

Is it hard to find things?

People leave when they cannot find what they came for. Broken links, confusing menus and buried pages all cause it.

Check these:

  • Can a new visitor find your main service, product or donation page in two clicks? - Do menu labels use plain words your customers would use, not internal jargon? - Do all buttons, forms and links work? Test them yourself every few months. - Does every page tell people what to do next?
  • A common mistake is adding more and more pages over time without ever tidying up. Remove what no longer helps and make the important routes obvious.

    Does your copy speak to the right person?

    If your ideal client cannot see themselves in your words, they will not act. Copy that tries to speak to everyone usually connects with no one.

    Write for one specific person. What are they worried about? What do they need to know before they trust you? A family looking for care support needs reassurance and clear next steps. A charity supporter needs to understand where their gift goes. A business buyer needs to know what working with you is like.

    Some practical tips:

  • Lead with the problem you solve, not a list of your features. - Use the words your customers use. Their reviews and emails are a good source. - Replace vague claims with specific detail, such as how your process works or what happens after someone gets in touch. - Make one clear request per page, such as "Book a call" or "Donate".
  • Does it work properly on mobile?

    This is a big one. Most people now browse and buy on their phones, so a site that only looks good on a desktop is losing business.

    Do not just check that the layout shrinks. Use the site on a real phone, with one thumb, on a normal connection. Can you tap the buttons without hitting the wrong one? Is the text readable without zooming? Do forms open the right keyboard? Does a pop-up cover the whole screen with a tiny close button?

    If the mobile version is awkward, people will not struggle through it. They will go to someone else.

    Is it slow?

    People are busy. A slow site feels like a closed door, and visitors will simply leave.

    Speed problems usually come from a few familiar causes:

  • Images uploaded at huge sizes and never compressed. - Too many plugins, tracking scripts or chat widgets. - Cheap hosting that struggles when traffic rises. - Auto-playing video on the homepage.
  • Start with the images, as they are often the quickest win. Then review what is running in the background and remove anything you do not use. A free speed testing tool will show you the biggest culprits.

    Do your postage options put people off?

    If you sell products, delivery costs can be the moment a basket is abandoned. Some people will simply not pay postage, however fair the price.

    You have two sensible options. You can build the cost into your product prices and offer free postage. Or you can take the hit for a promotional period and see whether conversions improve. Either way, track the results before deciding what to keep.

    Whatever you choose, be upfront. Show delivery costs and timings early, not for the first time at the final step. Surprise charges damage trust quickly.

    Is checkout too complicated?

    The closer someone gets to paying or sending their details, the less tolerance they have for effort. Do not ask for data you do not need. It slows people down and, under UK GDPR, you should only collect what you have a real reason to hold.

    Where you can, simplify checkout to one page. Offer guest checkout so people do not have to create an account. Show clear error messages, and keep the total visible throughout.

    The same applies to enquiry and donation forms. A care provider's contact form that asks for ten details will get fewer enquiries than one asking for a name, a phone number and a short message. You can always gather the rest in conversation.

    Common mistakes when fixing a website

    When conversions are low, it is tempting to redesign everything. That can be costly and does not always solve the real problem.

  • Changing lots of things at once, so you cannot tell what worked. - Relying on opinions instead of watching how people behave. - Fixing the homepage and ignoring the pages people actually land on. - Sending more traffic before fixing the basics.
  • A better approach is to work in order. Fix anything broken first. Then improve mobile and speed. Then sharpen your copy, and finally simplify checkout or forms. Make a change, give it time, and check what happened.

    Where to go from here

    A website that does not convert is not a failure. It is a prompt to look more closely at the experience you are offering. Ask real people for feedback, test the site on your phone, and remove anything that makes the next step harder than it needs to be.

    If you would like a second pair of eyes, we are happy to have a look at your website and work out why people are not converting.

    How healthy is your marketing?

    Take our free 60-second marketing health check.

    GET MY FREE SCORE

    Marketing tips for the sector

    Join our newsletter for practical health, care and charity marketing advice. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.